You Have a TMS. Why Is There Still So Much Manual Work?
Last updated:
Because a TMS is a system of record, not a system of action. It stores load data accurately and reports on it well. It does not search load boards, call brokers, negotiate, answer check calls or chase paperwork. Someone still does all of that and then types the result into the TMS.
What a TMS is actually for
Storing load records. Tracking status. Assigning drivers and equipment. Generating invoices from load data. Reporting on revenue, margin and utilization. Keeping compliance records.
All of it valuable, and all of it about information that already exists. A TMS is excellent at knowing what happened. It has no mechanism for making things happen.
Where the manual work actually is
Map a load from search to closeout and the TMS touches perhaps four of twelve stages:
| Stage | What the TMS does | Who does the work |
|---|---|---|
| Search load boards | Nothing | A person |
| Screen for profitability | Nothing | A person |
| Call brokers | Nothing | A person |
| Negotiate | Nothing | A person |
| Enter the booked load | Stores it | A person types it in |
| Brief the driver | Partly | A person |
| Track to pickup | Yes, if ELD-integrated | Nobody |
| Answer check calls | Nothing | A person |
| Handle exceptions | Nothing | A person |
| Collect documents | Stores them | A person files them |
| Invoice | Generates it | A person checks and sends it |
| Plan the next load | Nothing | A person |
The TMS is genuinely useful in four rows. In two of those, a person is still keying the data in. That gap is the manual work, and buying a better TMS does not close it, because it is not what a TMS does.
The three questions worth asking
Is the data getting in automatically, or is someone typing it? Re-keying rate confirmations is the single most common piece of avoidable work in a dispatch office, and it is also where invoice errors come from.
Is anything triggered by what the TMS knows? If the TMS shows a load delivered, does an invoice get prepared? If an ETA slips, does the broker hear? A record that nobody acts on is a report, not a workflow.
Is the TMS the source of truth, or one of several? If the driver was told one appointment time, the rate confirmation says another and the TMS a third, you do not have a system of record. You have three.
Fixing it without replacing the TMS
Replacing a TMS is expensive, disruptive, and usually does not solve this. You would get a better record of the same manual work.
Automate the data in. Rate confirmations parsed and written to the load record instead of retyped. Documents indexed automatically. Milestones from ELD geofences.
Automate the actions out. Status changes trigger broker notifications, invoice preparation and next-load planning, rather than sitting until someone notices.
Automate the work that never reaches the TMS at all. Searching, negotiating, check calls. None of it lives in a TMS today, and it is most of the hours.
Your TMS stays the system of record. What changes is that it stops being a place people type things.
What to look for in an automation layer
- Does it integrate with your specific TMS, or claim "most platforms"?
- Is the sync one-way or bi-directional?
- Does it write as work happens, or batch overnight?
- What happens when the TMS and the automation disagree?
- Can you see what it did, per load?
Ask for the list of TMS platforms a vendor actually connects to, by name. The connected tools page is that list for Hey Bubba!.
Frequently asked questions
A TMS records what happened. Searching, negotiating, calling brokers and answering check calls happen outside it, and the results get typed in.
Usually not. A different TMS gives you a better record of the same manual work. The gap is the work around it.
Yes. The TMS stays the system of record; automation performs the work and keeps the record current.
Invoice generation from load data, status reporting and compliance records. It is not built to search freight or communicate on your behalf.
Related
Hey Bubba! writes load records, documents and milestones to your TMS as work happens, and does the work that never reaches a TMS at all. See how
Last updated:
Automate the work behind your fleet.
See how the back office runs across your systems, your security review and your drivers, with the line between automated and human set by you.