You’re Taking Whatever Rate Is Posted
Last updated:
Not because you can’t negotiate, but because by the time you’ve finished with the last load, this one’s gone. Countering costs ten minutes you don’t have on a load worth two hundred dollars more, so it doesn’t happen. Across a year, that’s the difference between a good operation and a struggling one.
Why it happens
The math on your hour doesn’t justify it. Ten minutes to maybe gain $200 on one load, while three others go uncovered. Individually rational, cumulatively expensive.
Speed beats price on the board. A good load posted at 9am is covered by 9:20. Whoever calls first with a truck in the right place usually gets it, which rewards availability over negotiation.
You don’t have a number in mind. The strongest predictor of how a negotiation goes is whether you knew your floor before it started. Deciding load by load at 9pm produces inconsistent outcomes.
Nobody’s tracking what you left. An uncountered load doesn’t show up as a loss anywhere. It shows up as a rate you could have had, which appears in no report.
What actually moves a rate
Three things, and everything else is noise a broker hears daily:
Market data on that lane. “This lane’s been running $2.40 the last two weeks” is checkable and specific. “Rates are up” isn’t.
Proximity. If your truck is 20 miles out and their alternative is 200, that’s worth real money to a broker facing a pickup window. It’s the strongest card most carriers never play.
Willingness to walk. A floor only functions if it’s held. Brokers learn quickly which carriers split the difference every time.
What to do this week
- Set a floor per lane and write it down. Cost per mile plus target margin, adjusted for likely deadhead. Not a feeling: a number.
- Open 15 to 20% above it. Countering at your floor leaves nowhere to concede.
- Lead with proximity when you have it. Empty now, hours available, equipment ready. Brokers pay for coverage certainty.
- Track what you accept versus what you asked. If those numbers are always identical, you’re not negotiating.
More on negotiating with brokers
Get the terms, not just the rate
A $2.40 load with a two-hour detention clause into a facility that runs four-hour waits pays worse than a $2.30 load that turns quickly. Before agreeing, establish detention terms, whether fuel surcharge is included, lumper arrangements and payment schedule. The rate is one line of the deal.
Where Hey Bubba! fits
Hey Bubba! is an AI back-office automation platform for fleets. It counters on every load, including the ones that wouldn’t have been worth the phone call, opening above the floor you set, referencing spot market benchmarks, and working several brokers in parallel on the same lane. It holds the floor. If a broker won’t clear it, it walks or escalates to you.
Frequently asked questions
Around 15 to 20%, leaving room to concede without going below your number.
Generally not. Naming your floor turns it into the ceiling.
By hand, no; that’s exactly why it doesn’t happen. The calculation changes when countering costs nothing.
Then the question is whether the load clears your floor as posted. Walking is a correct outcome, not a failed negotiation.
Last updated:
Meet Bubba,
AI Back-Office
Automation for Fleets
Dispatch, paperwork & compliance - automated.
Just say Hey Bubba!